Gas vs Electric Water Heaters

Court Lundberg • October 8, 2024
Person using a screwdriver to work on a silver water heater, indoors.

If you’re in the market for a new water heater in Utah, then you’re probably trying to figure out what which model type will be best for your home. Two common types of water heaters are gas and electric, and each has its pros and cons. Here’s what you should know when shopping for water heaters.


What’s the Difference Between Gas and Electric Water Heaters?


Gas water heaters use gas-powered burners to heat the water that’s stored in a large tank. Electric water heaters use electric coils to heat the water in the tank and are powered with energy from your property’s electrical system.


Gas Water Heater Pro: Larger Tank Capacity


Large families may want to consider having a gas water heater installed in their homes to have plenty of hot water at their disposal. Gas water heaters typically have larger tanks than their electrical counterparts, being more energy efficient.


Gas Water Heater Pro: Faster Heating and Recovery Times


Gas water heaters can heat water more quickly than electric water heaters. If having lots of hot water available almost immediately is important to you, then consider a gas water heater.


Gas Water Heater Con: Significant Installation Requirements


To safely install and operate a gas water heater, you’ll need to have multiple components installed. Your new gas water heater will require a gas water hookup as well as sufficient ventilation to make sure that carbon monoxide doesn’t build up in your interior. A skilled plumber can install a gas water heater for you


Gas Water Heater Con: Lower Heating Efficiency Level


Gas water heaters heat an entire tank of water and then keep it heated to that temperature indefinitely. As a result, they must burn a decent amount of gas to keep the water within at the desired temperature.


Electric Water Heater Pro: Greater Variety of Options


Since you can buy both tanked and tankless electric water heaters, you’ll have more types of electric water heaters to choose from than gas water heaters. Tanked water heaters, like their gas counterparts, store water in bulk in large tanks. Tankless water heaters are smaller than traditional units and heat the water as it comes into the unit, providing hot water on demand.


Electric Water Heater Pro: Safe and Clean Operation


Water heaters running on electricity don’t burn gas, so you don’t have to worry about gas leaks or carbon monoxide exposure. You also don’t have to install special ventilation systems to handle excess fumes that you might encounter with gas water heaters.


Electric Water Heater Con: Slower Heating Rate


Due to their nature, electric water heaters warm water more slowly than their gas counterparts. If the speed at which your water heater warms water doesn’t matter to you, then this won’t be too much of a problem. However, if you frequently need a lot of hot water at your disposal, you might prefer a gas water heater.


Electric Water Heater Con: Requirement for Constant Electrical Connection


An electric water heater requires an electrical connection. If there is a power outage, your electric water heater cannot provide you with hot water. However, gas water heaters can operate during power failures to ensure hot water is available.


Quality Water Heater Installation in Bountiful, UT


At Rare Breed Plumbing, we pride ourselves in providing exceptional plumbing services to residents who live in Bountiful and the Salt Lake area. Our knowledgeable plumbers can take care of water heaters, sump pumps, garbage disposals, and plumbing system remodels. Whether you need quality water softeners, reverse osmosis filtering systems, repiping, or water line repair, we can help. Get in touch with us today if you want to learn more about our plumbing services or to schedule an appointment.

Court Lundberg explains water heater failure warning signs next to a cutaway tank showing the interi
By Court Lundberg July 17, 2026
Knowing the warning signs of a failing water heater can save you from a flooded utility room and an emergency replacement. Here's what to watch for in Utah homes.
Cast iron drain pipe interior corroded and eaten through by chemical drain cleaner in a Utah home.
By Court Lundberg July 13, 2026
Stop pouring chemical drain cleaner down your drain. I've seen it eat copper and cast iron clean through. Here's what actually clears a clog, from a Utah plumber.
Sewage backing up through a downstairs shower drain in a Utah home
By Court Lundberg July 7, 2026
Your sewer line warns you before it fails. Here are the signs I tell Utah homeowners to watch for, and the $350 check that saves you a $20,000 surprise.
White hard-water scale crusted on a bathroom faucet in a Utah home
By Court Lundberg July 2, 2026
Utah has the hardest water per capita in the nation. Here's what that white crust really is, what it's doing to your water heater, and how I'd stop it.
Pressure gauge and brass pressure reducing valve on a Utah home's main water line
By Court Lundberg June 29, 2026
Your house is not too old to have good water pressure. Here's how I find what's causing low water pressure, and the fixes you can try yourself first.
Utah homeowner conducting a spring plumbing maintenance check.
By Court Lundberg May 8, 2026
Use this 12-point spring plumbing maintenance checklist to protect your Utah home before summer. Practical tips from Rare Breed Plumbing, Heating, and Air.
Close-up of a water pressure gauge
By Court Lundberg April 23, 2026
Learn how to check water pressure at home, what PSI is normal, and when to call a plumber for help to protect your plumbing system. Read now!
Plumber inspects the plumbing under a sink
By Court Lundberg April 21, 2026
Get expert plumbing tips for spring, inspect your floor drains, sump pumps, and sewer lines before small issues turn into costly floods. Learn more!
Plumber under a kitchen sink inspecting pipes with tools on the floor
By Court Lundberg April 21, 2026
Use this annual plumbing inspection checklist to catch leaks, pressure issues, and failing equipment before they become costly disasters. Read now!
Man shutting off main water valve.
By Court Lundberg March 24, 2026
Finding the main water shut-off valve fast can prevent serious water damage. Learn where to locate it and how to shut off your home’s water main in an emergency.
Show More